Ripple Effect: Gravitational Waves Begin To Reveal A Hidden Universe

Monday February 22, 2016 11:00 am

To mark the start of a new era of astronomy, three principal researchers at the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory (LIGO) reflect on their epic discovery and how it will transform the way we see the cosmos.

SCIENTISTS HAVE ANNOUNCED THE FIRST direct detection of gravitational waves on Earth by the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory (LIGO). These elusive ripples in the fabric of space-time were first predicted by Albert Einstein a century ago. Yet until now, no instrument possessed the sensitivity needed to measure their incredibly subtle traces.

An international team of scientists made the major discovery shortly after LIGO was switched on in September 2015 following a multi-year upgrade. They published their findings online today in the journal Physical Review Letters.
What did the observatory’s twin detectors, located in Louisiana and Washington State, see? They each recorded a tiny vibration suggestive of gravitational waves passing through our planet. (Click here to learn more about how LIGO’s detectors work.) An analysis revealed the waves’ source: two inward spiraling black holes that smashed together to form a single black hole. It was the first time scientists had ever witnessed such a cataclysmic, space-warping event.
The monumental findings will open up an entirely new era of scientific investigation. Otherwise unknowable details of some of the universe’s most violent events—from neutron star and binary black hole mergers, to supernova explosions and even the Big Bang itself—should be revealed by the tell-tale gravitational waves they produce.

The Kavli Foundation spoke with three LIGO researchers, all part of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology’s Kavli Institute for Astrophysics and Space Research, about how studying gravitational waves will push Einstein’s theories to their limits and revolutionize our understanding of the cosmos at its extremes.    

The participants were:
Nergis Mavalvala – is the Curtis and Kathleen Marble Professor of Astrophysics and the Associate Department Head of Physics at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), and a member of the MIT Kavli Institute for Astrophysics and Space Research (MKI). Her LIGO work focuses on the development of instruments for making precise measurements.
Rainer Weiss – is a Professor of Physics, Emeritus at MIT and also a member of MKI. Rai was among the first to explore the kind of instrumentation necessary to detect gravitational waves and proposed the LIGO project with two colleagues in the 1980s.
Matthew Evans – is an Assistant Professor of Physics at MIT as well as a member of MKI. His work centers on gravitational wave detector science, including modeling and control of large interferometers like LIGO.
The following is an edited transcript of the roundtable discussion. The participants have been provided the opportunity to amend or edit their remarks.

How do you feel about this discovery?
Were you surprised at how fast Advanced LIGO detected gravitational waves?
Will these findings stand up to scrutiny?
What are the ramifications of this discovery?
Will LIGO help us study mid-size black holes?
What technological advances did this discovery hinge on?
Can we build even more sensitive detectors?
What is the future of gravitational wave research?
Could nearby astrophysical objects unleash sizeable gravitational waves?
THE KAVLI FOUNDATION: What does it feel like to have made this discovery? Rai, because you’re one of LIGO’s creators and someone who has pondered how to detect theses waves since the 1970s, let’s start with you.

RAI WEISS: You’re not going to like my answer—I feel like a monkey just jumped off my back! But the monkey’s not gone yet, he’s still walking along here on the sidewalk. We’ve got more to do. At least some of the guilty feelings that might have come from having dragged all these people along for decades hunting gravitational waves and maybe ruined their careers isn’t happening. So I am very pleased.

MATTHEW EVANS: If Rai had dragged us all toward our doom, it certainly would have been his fault. [Laughter] I hope he recognizes that he didn’t.

NERGIS MAVALVALA: It’s been a real joyride for decades and this is the pinnacle. It’s been amazing to be involved in the science and technology of this effort regardless, and this discovery just makes it all really worthwhile. I don’t think any of us ever feared we were being dragged to our doom. [Laughter] We were just on this great joyride where we didn’t know where we might end up.

TKF: This discovery of gravitational waves has been a long time in the making and required a lot of patience. Were you all actually surprised, then, at how quickly the detection was made after Advanced LIGO began operating back in September?
Nergis MavalvalaNergis Mavalvala’s work focuses on the development of instruments for making precise measurements with LIGO. (Credit: Nergis Mavalvala)


EVANS: Very pleasantly surprised.

WEISS: It’s amazing. The signal is bigger than we ever imagined it would be.

MAVALVALA: We had thought the first signal would be some little small thing poking up out of the noise and we’d have to work really hard to understand what it was. But in fact, the signal we got is a very clean and beautiful event. It tells us that the binary black holes were located about 1.5 billion light years away. They whirled around each other at nearly the speed of light before a collision that was so powerful, it converted approximately three times the mass of the Sun into gravitational wave energy—in just a few tenths of a second!

TKF: Two years ago, the BICEP2 Antarctic telescope project announced evidence for the signature of gravitational waves in light from 380,000 years after the Big Bang. But that major result came into question in early 2015 when other data suggested cosmic dust is a likelier source of the signature. Do you have any concerns about these LIGO findings?

EVANS: I don’t have any concerns about that. I’ve gone through the instruments from one end to the other and I couldn’t find anything that might have gone wrong. But the LIGO Scientific Collaboration, which is the umbrella organization for all the international institutions and scientists involved in this, is very well aware of the history. So the collaboration as a whole has been extremely careful to make sure this discovery is solid.

WEISS: The signal is so pretty, many of us worried at the time that it was something done maliciously. Matt and others crucially established that the signal is unlikely to have been generated by a hacker and much more likely by nature.

MAVALVALA: The other possibility was that the instruments were misbehaving, but we’ve gone through a very, very detailed study and eliminated that as a possibility.

WEISS: There’s one other piece of evidence—LIGO has detected more than one of these gravitational wave signals. That to me is a very important piece of the whole thing. Nature seems to behave as we would have expected, which is that it has produced not only a very powerful gravitational wave source like what we have detected and are talking about now, but also a not-so-powerful one of the same kind.

EVANS: Another thing really important to say in contrast to previously declared discoveries of gravitational waves is that we have multiple detectors running simultaneously which detected the same signal. At each site, we have literally thousands of auxiliary channels and sensors looking for any sort of external disturbance and everything checks out.

TKF: What do you think are the biggest ramifications of this discovery?

WEISS: For many of us, this is the signal that we wanted to see from the beginning of this whole quest. We wanted to see gravitation à la Einstein and his theory of general relativity and which cannot be explained by any Newtonian mechanisms. The history of general relativity as a science is actually rather dismal. It was mostly theoretical work for many, many years. Then there was a renaissance in the 1960s when people began to realize that maybe the technology had changed enough that you could start doing experiments to test Einstein’s theories. But then physicists ran into this really horrible problem that all the things that they could test were these infinitesimal effects. The bending of light, for example, is a pipsqueak effect. Or the slowing down of clocks in the gravitational field.

Now all of sudden with LIGO, we’re dealing with a regime where Einstein’s equations had never been applied before. With these colliding black holes, general relativity gives you the right answer, which is miraculous. That is the reason why this is such a big deal. Einstein never expected this kind of test of his theories to happen this way because the effects we’re looking for are so vanishingly small. I keep telling people I’d love to be able to see Einstein’s face right now!

MAVALVALA: Another thing that’s really remarkable is our ability to observe a binary black hole system with LIGO that we could not have observed with light. We could point the best telescopes, sensitive to more or less any electromagnetic wavelength of light, at this system and probably see nothing. We cannot observe this system with any of the other fundamental forces of nature. It has to be gravity.

If the signal LIGO had detected had been, say, neutron stars colliding and not black holes, we would have had no complaints, but there’s probably a very good chance you could see neutron star mergers with other, conventional observational tools relying on light. In fact, we believe that certain classes of gamma ray bursts are just that. So what we have here in the findings we’re announcing today is very important, in my opinion, because it’s a completely dark-to-light system.

EVANS: To me, this detection means that the stars are no longer silent. The frequencies of gravitational waves that LIGO is designed to detect are actually in the human audible range. So when we’re working on LIGO, we often take its output and put it on a speaker and just listen to it. For this binary black hole system, it made a distinctive, rising “whoooop!” sound. It’s not that we just look up and see anymore, like we always have—we actually can listen to the universe now. It’s a whole new sense, and humanity did not have this sense until LIGO was built.

WEISS: We often whistled to demonstrate what we thought these smashing black holes might sound like, and it turns out if you play the piano or a keyboard, you can also make a similar sound. Do you know what a glissando is? It’s when you run your fingers very quickly across the keys. If you started at the bottom of a keyboard and went all the way to the middle C and then hold that note for a little bit—that’s what this black hole signal happened to be.

“I keep telling people I’d love to be able to see Einstein’s face right now.”—Rai Weiss

TKF: It’s remarkable that the pattern or “sound” of gravitational waves detected by LIGO can reveal intricate details about the waves’ sources. For instance, LIGO’s data indicate that each black hole in this collapsing binary system had a mass of about 30 Suns. Until now, we’ve only known about much smaller black holes or supermassive black holes with masses of millions or billions of Suns. How will LIGO help us understand the origin of these never-before-seen, mid-size black holes?

EVANS: Presumably, the existence of these 30 solar-mass black holes—and now after their collision, a nearly 60-solar mass black hole—will tell us something about what we call Population III stars. These are the earliest stars in the universe and are made almost entirely out of hydrogen. They are very massive and one of the plausible sources we’ve suspected for collapsing into these kinds of black holes.

WEISS: Another idea is that these black holes are made in places where there is a high density of many millions of stars, for example in globular clusters. You can maybe get stars to stick together there and collect and ultimately make a big black hole. There were papers even before our discovery that were beginning to hint that this is the more likely way to get these objects. Now that our findings are out, you watch—in the next year or two, there are going to be probably hundreds of papers about the origin of the black holes we’re talking about. It’s going to be the wave of the future.

EVANS: The amazing thing at LIGO is that gravitational waves carry a tremendous amount of information about their source. As we get more and more of these detections, we’ll even be able to tell how fast the black holes in these binary systems are spinning and if they are spinning in a way that’s aligned. That data will let us decide whether these black holes came from a globular cluster or as a result of primeval Population III stars.
LIGOThe twin LIGO observatories in Hanford, Washington (top) and Livingston, Louisiana (bottom). (Credit: LIGO Scientific Collaboration)
What is LIGO?

LIGO is a physics experiment designed to measure gravitational waves reaching our planet from deep space. Gravitational waves are ripples in the fabric of the universe. First predicted to exist a century ago, they have now been directly detected.

Why are gravitation waves important?

Most of all our knowledge about the universe has come to us in the form of light, or electromagnetic radiation. Gravitational waves, however, are an entirely different form of radiation, produced by some of the most violent events in the universe, such as the collision of black holes. This newfound ability to “see” in gravitational waves will will further bolster our efforts to understand the universe.

LIGO consists of two detectors situated 1,865 miles (3,002 km) apart in isolated regions of the United States. Each facility has two 2.5-mile (4 km-) arms at right angles. Lasers are beamed down each arm and bounced back by mirrors. Sensitive detectors can tell if the length of the arms varies by as little as 1/10,000 the width of a proton due to passing gravitational waves.  Learn more
TKF: Turning our conversation to the LIGO observatories themselves—what technological advances did the black hole binary system discovery hinge on? Nergis, you were very involved in this aspect of the work, so please explain.

MAVALVALA: To build one of these gravitational wave detectors – these laser interferometers – you really only need two ingredients. One, you need mirrors that are very, very still. Then two, you need a way of measuring any very small motions. So the name of the game is having ways to shield mirrors from external, non-gravitational wave forces and having laser lights precise enough that you can probe the tiny motions that are induced by gravitational waves. Once you have those two things, you have yourself a detector.

The changes that granted us more sensitivity during Advanced LIGO were vibration isolation systems that were better than in the previous generation. In a slightly jargon-y way, we don’t use just passive isolation; we’re also using active vibration isolation. The other thing we had to do was reduce the vibrations of the mirrors due to thermally driven fluctuations. Then finally, we put in a more powerful laser so that our signal-to-noise ratio improved. The list of technologies involved in these improvement is very long, but those are the broad-brush strokes.

TKF: Matt, part of your work involves figuring out the fundamental limits for LIGO and for future gravitational wave detectors. How much more sensitivity to gravitational waves can we achieve and why do we want to?

EVANS: Putting first things first, we haven’t really gotten the Advanced LIGO detectors working as well as they can be. We will in some time. We think we can get a factor of three times as much sensitivity as we have currently, which could bring ten times as many gravitational wave-producing events into LIGO’s range. So we can expect a lot just from the Advanced LIGO detectors as we improve their function.

The next step we’re looking at is actually something that Nergis has pioneered, and that’s to use quantum optics in our detectors to reduce the quantum noise of the lights. Nergis talked about having lasers that were very precise and high-powered. But you can actually import techniques from a research field called quantum optics to try to reduce some of the randomness that’s inherent to light. Then, we’re looking farther into the future as to whether or not we can build detectors that are still another ten times more sensitive. That will probably involve a new facility and longer interferometers.
If you ask why we would want to do that, I think that we’ve just started this business. It looks like we have a lot of great physics and astrophysics we can do with these detectors. If we can make something ten times more sensitive, we’ll be able to detect gravitational wave sources from anywhere in the universe.
“We cannot observe this system with any of the other fundamental forces of nature. It has to be gravity.”—Nergis Mavalvala
TKF: With an even more advanced LIGO, as well as future gravitational-wave observatories, what other phenomena in the universe will we get understand in new ways?
WEISS: There is a whole spectrum of gravitational waves. With LIGO, we’re looking for high-frequency waves. As to how high we can go, again, the piano analogy is a wonderful one. Because what we’re looking for are sources that go from the bottom of the piano to the top of the piano. They don’t stop at middle C, which is currently our detection limit with LIGO. They go higher.
Beyond that, a lot of people are working in other frequencies and other wavelengths where there are phenomena which LIGO will not see. For example, we talked earlier about the BICEP project, which is looking for signatures of gravitational waves affecting the relic radiation from the Big Bang, called the cosmic microwave background. Well, that’s going to work someday, or it may be that a satellite has to do that observation. If there are gravitational waves from the first epochs of universe, they’re going to have periods, or cycles, that are stretched to on the order of the age of the universe itself, almost 14 billion years. So that’s the lower limit to the spectrum.
For another example, there’s a project that’s been going on almost as long as LIGO called the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna Project, or LISA. It involves lasers beamed between spacecraft with baselines that are up to five million kilometers, not four kilometers, like LIGO’s detection arms now, or even 40 kilometers like what Matt and Nergis want to do someday. LIGO can’t touch LISA’s detection spectrum, covering much longer wavelength. With LISA, there’s this wide open window with spectacular stuff in it, like binary white dwarf stars going around each other. Another is black holes with tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of the mass of the Sun, either colliding or having objects bend their orbit around them. You could do very, very careful tests of general relativity with that. I hope these other areas get dragged along by our discovery.

“To me, this detection means that the stars are no longer silent.”—Matthew Evans

TKF: Do you think there are any astrophysical objects in our galactic neighborhood that could unleash sizeable gravitational waves detectable by LIGO, or are all the major sources going to be far away?
EVANS: I suggest that we hope that there’s nothing close by. [Laughter] The binary black hole system we detected was 1.5 billion light years distant. That’s very, very far away, and in terms of how much energy was released so quickly, it was the most powerful explosion ever observed. So I think you wouldn’t want that in your neighborhood.
MAVALVALA: But maybe not too close, just within our galaxy…
EVANS: Well, a Milky Way event would probably saturate our detectors, but it’s not like it could hurt us or anything.
WEISS: Well, I hope you’re right about that! [Laughter] If we ever happen to be around when a supernova goes off, that would be as spectacular as what we have discovered now because we will see everything that is going on deep inside the supernova. Gravitational waves come right out. Nothing scatters these waves, which is the opposite of light that never gets out of the core of the explosion to tell us anything.
EVANS: I hate to get peoples’ hopes up for a supernova because they are so rare, but Rai is absolutely right. If we detect one in our galaxy, it would be a wonderful piece of physics.
MAVALVALA: I’ll add that I hate to get peoples’ hopes up for things we don’t even know how to articulate yet. We don’t fully know what’s out there with this new way of looking at the universe in gravitational waves. So it’s possible that there will be things maybe in our own galactic neighborhood, maybe far away, or maybe both that are just things we have not thought about yet.
EVANS: That’s very true. We’ve heard the loudest possible thing you could imagine go off and we got it, but hey, we’re just getting started.
—Adam Hadhazy, February 2016

Science Tags:
Gravitational Waves
Black Holes
Cosmic Microwave Background


Image:  A visualization of a supercomputer simulation of merging black holes sending out gravitational waves. (Credit: NASA/C. Henze)